Christopher Snyder’s The Making of Middle-earth: A New Look Inside the World of J.R.R. Tolkien offers readers a richly detailed exploration of the inspirations, influences, and intellectual foundations that shaped J.R.R. Tolkien’s legendary fictional world. This scholarly yet accessible work (revised edition 2022) stands as an essential companion for anyone seeking to understand the complex tapestry of mythological, linguistic, and historical threads that Tolkien masterfully wove into his literary creation.

The Scholar Behind the Story

Snyder, a medieval historian and professor at Mississippi State University, brings impressive academic credentials to his analysis of Tolkien’s world-building. Unlike many Tolkien scholars who approach the material primarily through literary criticism, Snyder’s background allows him to contextualize Tolkien’s creation within the historical and mythological traditions that influenced it. This perspective proves invaluable throughout the book, as Snyder meticulously connects Tolkien’s fictional elements to their real-world inspirations.

Structure and Content

The book is thoughtfully organized into thematic chapters that methodically examine different aspects of Tolkien’s creative process and influences. Beginning with biographical context, Snyder traces Tolkien’s early life, academic career, and the formative experiences that would later shape his fictional world. Particular attention is given to Tolkien’s traumatic experiences during World War I and how they informed his depiction of good versus evil in Middle-earth.

From there, Snyder delves into the linguistic foundations of Tolkien’s world – arguably the primary building block from which all other elements developed. As a philologist, Tolkien’s creation of Elvish languages preceded much of his mythology, and Snyder effectively demonstrates how these invented languages shaped the cultures, histories, and even geographies of Middle-earth. For Tolkien, language was not merely a tool for storytelling but the very essence from which his stories emerged.

The heart of the book explores the mythological, literary, and historical influences that informed Tolkien’s world-building. Snyder expertly analyzes connections between Middle-earth and Nordic mythology, Celtic legends, Arthurian romance, and Anglo-Saxon literature. Particularly strong is his examination of how “Beowulf” – a text Tolkien studied extensively throughout his academic career – provided crucial inspiration for elements ranging from Smaug the dragon to the cultures of Rohan.

What distinguishes Snyder’s analysis is his refusal to oversimplify. While identifying clear parallels between Tolkien’s creation and its influences, he also acknowledges the transformative nature of Tolkien’s imagination. Middle-earth was not merely a pastiche of borrowed elements but a cohesive secondary world that transcended its inspirations to create something genuinely original.

Visual Enrichment

The book is enhanced by thoughtful visual elements that complement the text. Maps, illustrations, and photographs help readers visualize both Tolkien’s world and its real-world inspirations. Particularly effective are comparisons of Middle-earth locations with their potential real-world counterparts, and illustrations of mythological figures that may have influenced Tolkien’s characters.

Scholarly Yet Accessible

One of the book’s greatest strengths is its balance between academic rigor and readability. Snyder writes with scholarly precision, grounding his analysis in thorough research and careful consideration of evidence. Yet his prose remains engaging and clear, making complex concepts accessible to general readers. This delicate balance allows the book to serve both as an introduction for newcomers to Tolkien scholarship and as a valuable resource for more experienced readers.

Snyder is careful to distinguish between documented influences and speculative connections, maintaining intellectual honesty throughout. When suggesting potential influences without direct evidence from Tolkien’s writings, he clearly frames these as possibilities rather than certainties – a refreshing approach in a field sometimes prone to overstatement.

Beyond the Movies

For readers whose primary experience with Middle-earth comes through Peter Jackson’s film adaptations, Snyder’s book offers a valuable broadening of perspective. While acknowledging the films’ importance in popularizing Tolkien’s work, Snyder maintains focus on the literary creation and its deeper meanings. This approach encourages readers to engage directly with Tolkien’s texts and the rich cultural traditions they draw upon.

Minor Shortcomings

If the book has a weakness, it lies in occasional repetition of certain themes across chapters. Some connections between Tolkien’s work and its inspirations are revisited multiple times, which can feel redundant to attentive readers. Additionally, while Snyder thoroughly examines the influences on Tolkien’s work, he devotes somewhat less attention to Tolkien’s own influence on subsequent fantasy literature and popular culture – an aspect that might have provided valuable context for understanding Middle-earth’s lasting significance.

Theological Dimensions

One particularly insightful aspect of Snyder’s analysis is his treatment of the religious and theological dimensions of Tolkien’s work. As a devout Catholic, Tolkien incorporated Christian themes into his mythology in subtle but profound ways. Snyder examines how Tolkien’s faith informed his conception of good and evil, his views on mortality and immortality, and his understanding of creation itself. This analysis helps explain the moral depth that distinguishes Tolkien’s work from many of its imitators.

The Making of Middle-earth stands as an essential contribution to Tolkien scholarship that simultaneously serves as an accessible entry point for general readers. Snyder’s expertise as a medieval historian brings fresh perspective to familiar material, illuminating connections that might escape notice in more narrowly literary analyses.

For serious Tolkien enthusiasts, the book provides a deeper understanding of the vast cultural heritage that informed Middle-earth’s creation. For casual fans, it offers an engaging introduction to the complex foundations underlying a beloved fictional world. And for those interested in creative processes more generally, it demonstrates how a singular imagination can transform diverse influences into something entirely new.

At a time when fantasy literature and media continue to dominate popular culture, Snyder’s book reminds us of the exceptional depth and thoughtfulness behind Tolkien’s pioneering work. By revealing the scholarly foundations of Middle-earth, Snyder helps us appreciate anew the remarkable achievement that continues to captivate readers nearly a century after Bilbo Baggins first stepped out of his comfortable hobbit-hole and into adventure.

Whether you’re a longtime Tolkien scholar or simply curious about how Middle-earth came to be, Snyder’s illuminating study deserves a place on your bookshelf – ideally right beside the dog-eared copies of The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings that inspired your journey into Tolkien’s world in the first place.

---

Part of a regular series on 27gen, entitled Wednesday Weekly Reader.

During my elementary school years one of the things I looked forward to the most was the delivery of “My Weekly Reader,” a weekly educational magazine designed for children and containing news-based current events.

It became a regular part of my love for reading, and helped develop my curiosity about the world around us.