In a world brimming with information, one of the most powerful yet underused reading strategies is synoptical reading. More than a technique, synoptical reading is a discipline of synthesis – of drawing together multiple perspectives on a subject to cultivate depth, clarity, and wisdom. Whether you’re a student, scholar, leader, or lifelong learner, this approach can transform the way you learn, think, and engage with complex ideas.
What Is Synoptical Reading?
Think of synoptical reading as the ultimate book conversation – it’s what happens when you gather multiple authors around the same topic and let them hash it out. Mortimer Adler and Charles Van Doren called this the highest form of reading* in their classic How to Read a Book, and for good reason. Instead of just absorbing what one author tells you, synoptical reading involves collecting different books on the same subject and playing intellectual detective, looking for patterns, contradictions, and those “aha!” moments when seemingly unrelated ideas suddenly click together. It’s like being a moderator at a debate where the participants wrote their arguments decades or even centuries apart.
You’re not just reading – you’re orchestrating a dialogue between minds, asking tough questions, and building something new from the collision of different perspectives.
This approach becomes incredibly powerful because it reveals how ideas evolve over time, exposes the blind spots that individual authors might miss, and often leads to insights that none of the original writers could have reached alone. In our current world of endless information streams, synoptical reading is less about consuming more content and more about becoming a thoughtful curator who can weave together the best thinking on complex topics into something genuinely illuminating.
How It Works: An Example from the Guest Experience Field
Let’s say you’re exploring the topic of guest experience – a concept that blends hospitality, emotional connection, intentional design, and cultural insight. A traditional approach might involve reading one well-known book, such as Horst Schulze’s Excellence Wins. But synoptical reading invites a broader, more layered view.
Drawing from the curated titles in The Essential Guest Experience Library, here’s how you might construct a synoptical reading list to explore guest experience from multiple vantage points:
- Legacy + Leadership
Excellence Wins by Horst Schulze (co-founder of The Ritz-Carlton) offers both operational philosophy and personal leadership wisdom. His insistence that “ladies and gentlemen serve ladies and gentlemen” reframes guest experience as a matter of dignity and culture-building. - Disney + Storytelling
Be Our Guest by the Disney Institute and Theodore Kinni introduces the power of intentional systems, story-driven environments, and on-stage/off-stage discipline in delivering consistent, magical experiences. Disney’s approach models scalability without sacrificing soul. - Design + Empathy
The Power of Moments by Chip and Dan Heath provides insight into why certain interactions are remembered, shared, and treasured. Their framework – elevation, insight, pride, and connection – shifts guest experience from process to emotionally charged encounter. - Culture + Soul
Unreasonable Hospitality by Will Guidara tells the story of transforming Eleven Madison Park into the world’s best restaurant – not through food alone, but by making every guest feel seen. Guidara shows how irrational generosity creates unforgettable moments of belonging. - Framework + Execution
The Experience by Bruce Loeffler (former Disney leader) and Brian Church translates guest experience into a practical framework for leadership teams. It’s ideal for organizations that want to operationalize hospitality while keeping the heart intact.
With this synoptical approach, you start to see how different disciplines – luxury hotels, theme parks, fine dining, and organizational strategy – converge around a shared mission: to create experiences that delight, transform, and endure.
But you’ll also uncover key distinctions. Schulze emphasizes honor and systems; Guidara focuses on emotional generosity and improvisation. The Heath brothers bring psychological insight, while Loeffler provides templates for execution. Disney stands alone in institutionalizing storytelling at scale. Synthesizing these voices allows you to not only appreciate their individual brilliance but also build your own blueprint tailored to your context – whether that’s a nonprofit, church, café, or global brand.
Why Synoptical Reading Matters
In our age of information overload, it’s easy to get lost in isolated data points or become trapped in ideological echo chambers. Synoptical reading offers a structured antidote. Here’s why it’s so powerful:
- It Develops Intellectual Humility
By reading widely and across viewpoints, you’re less likely to idolize a single author or framework. It teaches you that no one has the full picture – and that’s a good thing. True wisdom lies in nuance.
- It Cultivates Critical Thinking
Synthesizing multiple arguments requires you to detect assumptions, biases, logical fallacies, and philosophical underpinnings. It sharpens your ability to ask, “Compared to what?” and “Why does this matter?”
- It Deepens Retention and Understanding
Rather than passively reading and forgetting, synoptical reading demands active comparison. This act of mental wrestling increases comprehension and memory, much like cross-training enhances athletic performance.
- It Encourages Independent Thought
By creating your own terms of discussion and evaluating authors from a higher level, you stop parroting others and begin forming your own reasoned judgments. You become not just a reader, but a thinker.
- It Enhances Application and Problem-Solving
Most real-world challenges are not solved by one theory alone. Whether you’re addressing generational shifts in leadership, reimagining guest experiences, or tackling ethical dilemmas, synoptical readers draw from multiple wells.
How to Practice Synoptical Reading
This kind of reading is less about volume and more about intentionality. Here’s a simple framework to start:
- Define the Question
What are you trying to understand? The best synoptical reading starts with a real-life tension or curiosity. - Build a Bibliography
Choose 3–5 books from different traditions, disciplines, or ideological standpoints. Don’t just read what confirms your bias – include thoughtful dissenters. - Skim First, Then Dive
Begin by skimming each book for structure, terminology, and core claims. This survey will help you create a shared vocabulary across books. - Take Comparative Notes
Use a matrix or chart to track how each author defines key terms, frames the problem, and suggests solutions. Note contradictions, insights, and shared themes. - Write a Synthesis
Summarize your findings. Where do the books align or diverge? What do they miss? What’s your take, and how has it changed?
Final Thought: Reading as Dialogue, Not Consumption
Synoptical reading reimagines books not as static containers of information but as conversation partners. Each author speaks from their vantage point, but you – the reader – host the dialogue, ask the questions, and ultimately offer the conclusion.
In a time when complexity is often flattened into soundbites and certainty is prized over curiosity, synoptical reading revives the art of intellectual hospitality. It invites divergent voices to the table, listens carefully, and offers back something wiser than any single book could contain.
If reading is a feast, synoptical reading is the banquet.
* A NOTE ABOUT WORD USEAGE: Syntopical and synoptical reading are often used interchangeably, but there’s a subtle distinction between the two, though both represent the highest and most demanding level of reading. Both methods involve reading multiple books on the same subject to gain a deep understanding of a topic. However, syntopical reading, as defined by Mortimer Adler is about creating a new perspective on a topic by putting authors in conversation with each other. While synoptical reading is also about comparing texts, it’s a broader term and not as systematic as the syntopical method described by Adler. Both approaches go beyond merely understanding a single book, pushing the reader to create new knowledge and a comprehensive understanding of a topic through rigorous comparison and analysis.
My bias has been to use the “synoptical” as that was the term I was introduced to while in graduate school (syntopical was not in the dictionary, and thus not useable in graduate work), and it has stuck with me since. That being said, the process defined by Adler is closer to what I refer to in this article.
Part of a regular series on 27gen, entitled Wednesday Weekly Reader.
During my elementary school years one of the things I looked forward to the most was the delivery of “My Weekly Reader,” a weekly educational magazine designed for children and containing news-based current events.
It became a regular part of my love for reading, and helped develop my curiosity about the world around us.
27gen.com 